
Photo credit: Robbie Mehling/Soc Takes
Over the course of the last several years, the U.S. Soccer Federation created an impetus among the leadership of the USL to bring every club into compliance with every FIFA guideline regarding player contracts. As of the end of the 2017 season, USL clubs were more consistently and completely adhering to FIFA guidelines than clubs in the NASL or MLS. The USL made a strong commitment to meet FIFA standards for all player contracts in the league’s effort to be recognized as a sanctioned Division II league by the USSF.
With this background, it comes as a surprise that one USL expansion club has a contract addendum that not only doesn’t meet FIFA guidelines, but seems to undermine the long-term spirit of the way the USL has handled player contracts.
The player contract for the USL expansion side obtained by Soc Takes includes the following language applicable to players with semi-guaranteed deals as an amendment to the standard USL player contract:
“Semi-Guaranteed Player Status: Except as specifically set forth in Section I.B. below, and for the complete avoidance of doubt as it relates to all sections of the Player Agreement (including, but not limited to, Section 1, 16, 18 & Addendum B), Player further agrees and acknowledges that (name redacted) may terminate Player Agreement at any time during the term of the Player Agreement in the Club’s sole discretion. In the event of an early termination of the Player Agreement, Club agrees to pay Player the pro-rata amount of salary due to him as of the date of the termination and shall be under no further obligation to provide any additional compensation (including, but not limited to housing, insurance, etc.) except as specifically required by law (e.g., COBRA insurance coverage, etc.).”
Our understanding is that this clause is not being introduced league wide and not being used as addendum to other player contracts with expansion teams in the league. However, it is possible if the club has success in implementing this clause, other USL teams looking to cut costs and depress wages might follow. It also could serve as an example of the type of cost-cutting player contract addendum we might see in other U.S. professional leagues.
- Related: What USL documents tell us about Tommy Heinemann saga
Through the years, the USL has made an effort to ensure professional players are in professional environments. Not long ago, many players — if not most — outside Major League Soccer were often found holding down second, third and even fourth jobs just to make ends meet.
These days, many players can survive during the season on their USL salaries alone. But now, perhaps given the diminishing revenues across the lower divisions, austerity might begin to reign again in terms of player salaries.
UPDATE
In response to this report, a USL official responded with the following comment:
“The USL has invested heavily in player standards over the years, and its Compliance Department closely monitors these issues across the league to ensure we meet USSF and FIFA regulations. This addendum issue was an isolated occasion with a new expansion club that mistakenly included non-compliant language to their player contracts. As soon as they learned of this issue, the Compliance Department moved quickly to work with the club and ensure these contracts were nullified, and new compliant contracts were executed with the players prior to the new season. The department also reached out to every club in the league, reemphasizing that all contracts are guaranteed by FIFA regulations, and such addendums are not acceptable.
We are committed to upholding player standards across the USL, and we take very seriously our compliance with U.S. Soccer Federation and FIFA player contract regulations. Our team works hard to ensure all the league’s clubs maintain the highest standards, and we continue to build upon that.”
Follow Kartik on Twitter: @kkfla737.
Support Soc Takes on Patreon for access to exclusive content and supporter benefits. Click here to become a patron today.


Photo credit: Robbie Mehling/Soc Takes


The lower divisions of American soccer are a tumultuous place. Whether it is the collapse of individual clubs, irresponsible behavior toward players or the death of an entire league, the stories of instability are as commonplace as a PBR at your local dive bar. Yet, there is one narrative…
While the NASL lawsuit appeal rolls on, US Soccer finds itself in a situation where, for a second year running, it starts the calendar year without a sanctioned second division. Unlike the NASL, USL has continued to make expansion announcements and USL teams have diligently continued to rebuild their…
CARY, N.C. — In their 50th season, the Indiana University men’s soccer team was 90 minutes away from the perfect ending to the season — a ninth national championship. The…
Anyone who watched the Indiana Hoosiers men’s soccer team this season had their doubts. The Hoosiers would come together and play great one minute. And 10-15 minutes later, it…
MUNCIE, Ind. — Western Michigan cooled off an in-form Ball State squad with a 2-nil road win on Oct. 9. The Cardinals had previously been unbeaten across their last…
LOUISVILLE, Ky. — Goals by Sophia Smith and Hina Sugita helped the Portland Thorns to a 2-1 road win over Racing Louisville on Friday at Lynn Family Stadium. Alex Chidiac provided the lone tally for the hosts. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon for access to…
FORT WAYNE, Ind. — Fort Wayne FC shut out the visiting Cleveland Force 3-0 on Saturday behind a brace by Maxwell Amoako and an own goal by Cleveland goalkeeper Andrew Cooke. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon for access to exclusive content and supporter benefits. Click here to…
INDIANAPOLIS — Playing in its first game at Carroll Stadium, the Indy Eleven women wrapped up an undefeated USL W League regular season with a 3-0 win Saturday against Detroit City FC. In the nightcap, the DCFC men’s side bested Indy 1-0 in USL Championship play. Follow Robbie on…
LOUISVILLE, Ky. — Goals by Paige Monaghan and Taylor Smith helped lead Gotham FC to a 2-1 road win at Racing Louisville on Friday. Savannah DeMelo provided the lone tally for the hosts. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon for access to exclusive content and supporter…
PITTSBURGH — Albert Dikwa’s volley in the 79th minute Wednesday delivered the Pittsburgh Riverhounds a 1-nil victory over the visiting Indy Eleven at Highmark Stadium. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon for access to exclusive content and supporter benefits. Click here to become a patron today….
NASHVILLE, Tenn. — The visiting Portland Timbers rallied from 2-nil down to draw Nashville SC 2-2 on Sunday at Nissan Stadium. Goals by Nashville’s Sean Davis and Hany Mukhtar were canceled out by strikes from Dairon Asprilla and Jaroslaw Niezgoda. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon…
INDIANAPOLIS — A 58th-minute tally by Joshua Perez carried Miami FC to a 1-0 road victory at Indy Eleven on Saturday evening. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon for access to exclusive content and supporter benefits. Click here to become a patron today….
HAMTRAMCK, Mich. — The undefeated Indy Eleven traveled to Keyworth Stadium on Friday, topping Detroit City FC 3-0 while moving their record in USL W League play to 8W-2D-0L. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon for access to exclusive content and supporter benefits. Click here to become a…
FORT WAYNE, Ind. — Fort Wayne FC hosted a friendly with Tigres’ reserve side Wednesday at Shields Field, with the teams settling for a 1-1 draw. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon for access to exclusive content and supporter benefits. Click here to become a patron today….
FORT WAYNE, Ind. — Fort Wayne FC topped visiting Toledo Villa FC 2-0 on Saturday in USL League Two play behind goals from Victor Claudel and Riley Lynch. Fort Wayne sits in first place after collecting 18 points in nine matches. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on…
WESTFIELD, Ind. — In a battle of USL W League Great Lakes Division leaders on Friday at Grand Park, the Indy Eleven bested Racing Louisville FC 3-1 to take over first place in the standings, bumping Louisville to second. Follow Robbie on Twitter: @RobbieMeh. Support Soc Takes on Patreon for…
FORT WAYNE, Ind. — Fort Wayne FC hosted FC Cincinnati 2 for a friendly Tuesday, and goals on either side of halftime led to a 1-1 scoreline at fulltime. FC Cincy 2 plies its trade in the MLS Next Pro league, while Fort Wayne FC is a member of…
National Independent Soccer Association (NISA) founder Peter Wilt joins the panel to discuss the newly forming league, his former clubs and all things U.S. Soccer. Wilt helped launch the Chicago Fire, Chicago Red Stars and Indy Eleven, to name a few. Soc Takes contributing writer Kartik Krishnaiyer also guests…
The North American Soccer League lost the important part of its lawsuit relating to Division 2 sanctioning, and as a result has cancelled the planned 2018-19 season. Of the eight teams that participated in the 2017 campaign, two have already folded. The San Francisco Deltas won the title and…
Community-based amateur soccer is in many ways the lifeblood of the growth of American soccer on the grassroots level. The remarkable recent growth of local supporters culture taking the best of European traditions and marrying them with small and medium-sized town America is one of the great untold stories…
Recently, we discussed the potentially troubling interpretation of the USL’s player contract in the contract termination of FC Cincinnati’s Tommy Heinemann. From our perspective, the troubling clauses in the USL contract have the potential to be abused to limit the validity of player contracts. Unfortunately, another similar contractual clause exists…
As originally reported by Soc Takes contributor Kartik Krishnaiyer, this weekend, Jacksonville Armada owner Robert Palmer will meet with interested owners about launching an unsanctioned league. Sunday @JaxArmadaFC owner Robert Palmer will convene a “Division Zero” Task Force meeting in Orlando. Among the topics to be discussed are how…
On Wednesday, Miami FC announced that they will play a team in the NPSL. This story was originally reported by Soc Takes. Soc Takes reached out to Miami FC CEO Sean Flynn, via email, to ask a few questions about Wednesday’s news: Nipun Chopra – Jacksonville Armada has introduced…
As the Beckham-Miami group is scheduled to announce their MLS expansion news on Monday, Miami FC is expected to make an announcement of their own. Miami FC will field a team in the National Premier Soccer League (NPSL) during the league’s 2018 season which runs from March through August….
This morning, Miami FC are expected to announce Paul Dalglish as their next head coach. The team – widely considered to be one of the strongest in lower division soccer – is currently still scheduled to play in the NASL. Dalglish – the son of Liverpool legend Kenny Dalglish…
Inverted Triangle Soccer Podcast host and WRAL Sports writer Neil Morris returns to the Soc Takes Pod to discuss the Indy Eleven’s hiring of new head coach Martin Rennie. Morris covered Rennie up close and personal from 2009-11 during Rennie’s tenure with the then-Carolina RailHawks. Co-hosts Aaron Gunyon and…
As the NASL awaits the court’s decision, all the uncertainty has certainly affected players and front office personnel negatively. In a letter sent to the 10 remaining players on the Jacksonville Armada roster, team owner Robert Palmer has attempted to ameliorate some of their concerns by declaring that they…
Co-hosts Lance McGarvey and Jeff Milby invite Soc Takes staff writer Nipun “The Dr. of DII” Chopra on the latest edition of “Soccer City” presented by LouCity to make sense of his breaking story that the Indy Eleven are migrating to the USL. The move is expected to officially…
During his press conference today, Robert Palmer, owner of Jacksonville Armada FC, suggested that a USL ownership group had been interested in playing in Jacksonville — one that was also attempting to secure Hodges Stadium as its stadium of choice. Interesting tidbit from Palmer around the time of his…